RSS

The HIV Murders Club

Ayanna Nahmias, Editor-in-Chief
Last Modified: 18:11 PM EDT,  7 March 2012

Blood DropMASVINGO PROVINCE, Zimbabwe – Shocking news hit the internet six days ago when a 17-year-old HIV positive maid from Mupandawana, Gutu, was sentenced to a 10-year prison term for trying to infect her employer’s four-year-old child with the HIV virus.

People deliberately infecting other people with the virus that causes AIDS is a very real problem both here and abroad. Perpetrators engage in this type of immoral behavior for a number of reasons including denial, anger and revenge.

In the case of Pelagia Mureya, originally from Choto Village in Chief Magonde area in Chinhoyi, she is purported to have sought revenge by putting menstrual blood in porridge which she prepared for her employer’s child. She alleged that this was done in retaliation for the ill-treatment to which she was subjected at the hands of her employers. (For information on how HIV is transmitted visit the CDC website here.)

On 11 September 2011, the ABC News program 20/20 featured a report about Philippe Padieu, who was convicted in 2009 for infecting several women with HIV between the years 2004 to 2007. Padieu, actively pursued his victims, convinced them that he was HIV negative, psychologically manipulated them into engaging in unprotected sex with him, and then discarded them when his interest waned or the money ran out.

Padieu was subsequently convicted in a Texas court of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon for infecting the women and sentenced to 45-years in prison.


In featuring the Mureya case, we also presented Padieu’s case to provide balance, because perpetrators of this crime come from all backgrounds. It was especially important to provide this juxtaposition because many of the comments that readers wrote on other sites that reported on Mureya’s case were either outright racist or had racial overtones.

This does not excuse the heinous and disgusting manner with which Mureya tried to infect the infant in her care, and from a moral standpoint, both she and Padieu should be considered monsters.

It is alleged by the court and the parents of the 4-year old child that Mureya laced the porridge she was feeding the child with drops of her infected menstrual blood. Even the most callous individual would be incensed at the thought of such an unclean substance being ingested by an innocent and trusting child who is ill-equipped to protect themselves against harm.

This post does not defend Mureya’s behavior, and in fact, we believe that the 10-year prison term to which she was sentenced was not harsh enough when a two-year reduction in sentence for good behavior is factored into the equation. Mureya’s case would evoke a visceral response in almost anybody, and thus reports of this case have focused on the sensational aspect rather than the fact that a child was used by an adult to exact vengeance on another adult.

The Nahmias Cipher Report’s primary mission is to attempt to bring balance in reporting about people of the Continent and in other Emerging Economies. This is why we chose to present an alternative perspective to this story, one that would make readers realize that the deliberate infection of healthy people with the HIV virus is more prevalent than one would think. To that end, though this case is sensational, it is not an isolated occurrence, nor is this crime a uniquely ‘black,’ ‘African,’ or ‘impoverished people’ problem. If you think you are safe, just ask the women assaulted by Padieu.

Follow Nahmias Cipher Report on Twitter
Twitter: @nahmias_report
Editor: @ayannanahmias</address

, , , , , , , , , , , ,

About Ayanna Nahmias

Ayanna Nahmias was interviewed on Radio Netherlands Worldwide program titled 'The State We’re In,' about her life in Africa and her determination to transcend her past. She started the Nahmias Cipher Report to provide information to readers about life in emerging economies, and to provide alternative insight into the challenges faced by women and children living in these countries. The blog features stories from around the world to inspire other people to persevere and triumph in the face of great adversity. She blogs about current events in emerging economies, international politics, human rights abuses, women’s rights and child advocacy.

View all posts by Ayanna Nahmias

3 Comments on “The HIV Murders Club”

  1. theeyeoffaith Says:

    Very interesting story, indeed. I would be wary of reporting such a story, especially in context to the situation here in North America with HIV. More and more information and data is being discovered everyday regarding HIV and it’s important to stay relevant to this information- the truth.

    Truth is- the chance of infection from HIV-infected blood being cooked into porridge is pretty much NILL. Center for Disease Control quotes:

    “No incident of food being contaminated with HIV-infected blood or semen has been reported to CDC. Furthermore, CDC has received no reports of HIV infection resulting from eating food, including condiments.

    HIV does not live long outside the body. Even if small amounts of HIV-infected blood or semen was consumed, exposure to the air, heat from cooking, and stomach acid would destroy the virus. Therefore, there is no risk of contracting HIV from eating food.”

    Makes you wonder? Seems like the nurse’s HIV-infection is more convenient for her employers. Don’t you think they must’ve been awful to her if she was trying this? Can’t imagine the situation being good.

    The criminalization of HIV is one of the most flawed aspects of the legal system. Sort of, a disgrace to mankind.

    So I’d definitely re-examine the situation at hand. I don’t think what the maid did was right by any means, but there is definitely a bigger story to be told here.

    Sincerely,

    -The Eye x

    Reply

    • Ayanna Nahmias Says:

      I emphatically agree with you. When I wrote the post I didn’t focus on the aspect of transmission and whether the child could have actually been infected by this method of transmission. I ‘assumed,’ something which should never be done, that most readers would be educated enough to realize that this type of transmission was not viable. I also agree that the woman was obviously very upset about some type of abuse that occurred, and felt that this was her only means of redress.

      The criminalization of HIV is not acceptable, but the individuals who knowingly infect others must be held accountable for the subterfuge they practice by using this invisible weapon. Most crimes are crimes of opportunity wherein the perpetrators uses items at hand such as knives, sticks, bats, tire irons, bottles, etc. In the case of HIV+ people who KNOWINGLY infect others, they are using their bodies and their blood to hurt others and this cannot be condoned.

      Resources about HIV transmission: http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/resources/qa/transmission.htm

      Thank you so much for reading the article and taking the time to comment. ~ Ayanna Nahmias

      Reply

  2. ecofinanalysis Says:

    So complex are human minds… the innocent suffer…

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 6,108 other followers

%d bloggers like this: